• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • About Us
  • Videos
    • Featured Video
    • Foodie Friday
    • Monthly ReCap
  • Online E-Editions
    • This Week’s E-Editions
    • 2023
    • 2022
    • 2021
    • 2020
    • 2019
    • 2018
    • 2017
    • 2016
    • 2015
    • 2014
  • Social Media
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Instagram
  • Advertising
  • Local Jobs
  • Puzzles & Games
  • Circulation Request

The Laker/Lutz News

Serving Pasco since 1981/Serving Lutz since 1964

       

Click to join our weekly e-newsletter

  • Home
  • News
    • Land O’ Lakes
    • Lutz
    • Wesley Chapel/New Tampa
    • Zephyrhills/East Pasco
    • Business Digest
    • Senior Parks
    • Nature Notes
    • Featured Stories
    • Photos of the Week
    • Reasons To Smile
  • Sports
    • Land O’ Lakes
    • Lutz
    • Wesley Chapel/New Tampa
    • Zephyrhills and East Pasco
    • Check This Out
  • Education
  • Pets/Wildlife
  • Health
    • Health Events
    • Health News
  • What’s Happening
  • Sponsored Content
    • Closer Look
  • Homes
  • Obits
  • Public Notices
    • Browse Notices
    • Place Notices

Amendment 4 asks voters to check growth

October 19, 2010 By Special to The Laker/Lutz News

By Molly McGowan

It’s been called the “Vote on Everything” amendment by skeptics and considered the cure to the “boom and bust” cycle of real estate by proponents, but on Nov. 2, Amendment 4 on the ballot will be called by a more complex name.

Supporters of Amendment 4 cite the Connerton development as an example of why citizens should have more power to approve development. The Land O’ Lakes community has only a few hundred of the 8,500 planned homes. (File photo)

Voters will see this title: “Referenda required for adoption and amendment of local government comprehensive land use plans.” In layman’s terms: “Should voter approval be required for changes to growth management plans? Should voters be able to veto a plan because they don’t approve of the new blueprint for their city or county or of new proposed developments?”
Cynics say no, that Amendment 4 would just create more taxpayer expenses, resulting from litigation that would inevitably follow vetoes to changes in land use plans. According to the Florida Chamber of Commerce, one of Amendment 4’s most staunch opponents, city and county governments would have to hold referenda on upwards of hundreds or thousands of referenda annually, which would be quite costly.
That’s the main point that the opposition wants voters to be aware of — that Amendment 4 could be potentially costly for taxpayers, and more of a hassle than a privilege when it comes to voting time.
Adam Babington, vice president of governmental affairs at the chamber, said that under Amendment 4, the cost of holding elections would be between $44 and $83 million a year and litigation expenses could hit a billion dollars for the state of Florida.
Babington stated that “it’s pretty clear Florida is still in a recession,” and that Amendment 4 would only make things worse for taxpayers.
Meanwhile, those backing the amendment argue that it’s important for voters to realize the power and influence that voting “yes” on Amendment 4 would give them in the state government. Wayne Garcia, communications director for Florida Hometown Democracy, said Amendment 4 would give taxpayers and citizens the control they deserve over the land use system, allowing them to help decide how available land will be used, and which developments will be built where.
Garcia said that since it’s the taxpayer’s dollars that pay for changes in land use plans, they should be directly involved in the decision-making processes. Garcia also said the argument that Amendment 4 would increase election costs is invalid; the Department of Community Affairs tracked how many land use amendments there had actually been over the past few years, and came up with an average of 4.2 a year.
Garcia and other Amendment 4 supporters regard Land O’ Lakes’ Connerton neighborhood as an example of why Amendment 4 should be put into place. According to Garcia, the empty lots that were approved for homes within the development are now just a waste of space, and are examples of a “boom and bust” cycle of real estate that could be checked under Amendment 4.
Garcia also cites the city of St. Pete Beach as proof that there wouldn’t be an obscene amount of amendments proposed annually under Amendment 4. Garcia said the city of St. Pete Beach reviewed every comprehensive land use change since 2005 and found 25 proposed amendments, of which only 22 were approved and would have gone to election.
Spread across four election periods, only five or six of those amendments would have appeared annually on ballots under the amendment. Garcia said that this number of amendments would be reasonable for Florida voters, and that over time, would probably decrease. “I think there will be even fewer amendments once people learn to live within their means and their comprehensive plans,” Garcia said.
Babington and the Florida Chamber of Commerce look at St. Pete’s charter with a much more critical eye and see the attempt as a failure. Babington said that within 24 hours of amendments being drawn up for the city in 2008, a series of lawsuits and complaints were filed.
Babington said that over the course of the following year, the local government had incurred over $5,000 in litigation fees and by September 2009, property taxes had to be raised in order to help pay for them. So Babington – and the rest of the amendment’s opponents – view Amendment 4 as a surefire failure waiting to happen. “This isn’t just speculation of how it’s going to work,” Babington said. “We have a case study of how it’s worked in Florida, and it’s failed miserably.”
Florida Hometown Democracy countered that the expensive litigation that resulted in St. Petersburg was a result of developers who wanted to build enormous hotels on the waterfront and negatively affect the city’s population density, and not of the change in the charter.
Regardless of what ultimately caused the litigation expenses in St. Petersburg, decisions on Amendment 4 will ultimately be based on whether they believe more direct control in their government is worth having to make more decisions on future ballots.

Early voting
Don’t wait until Election Day to sound off on Amendment 4 and other issues. Early voting started this week and continues through Saturday, Oct. 30. Most locations allow voting 10 a.m. to 6 p.m. There will no voting on Sunday, Oct. 24.

Hillsborough early voting sites
Jimmie B. Keel Regional Library, 2902 W. Bearss Ave. in Carrollwood
New Tampa Regional Library, 10001 Cross Creek Blvd. in New Tampa
County Center, 601 E. Kennedy Blvd. in Tampa (9 a.m. to 5 p.m.)
More locations at www.votehillsborough.org

Pasco early voting sites
(Saturday hours are 10 a.m. to 5 p.m.)
Land O’ Lakes Branch Library, 2818 Collier Parkway in Land O’ Lakes
Village Market of Wesley Chapel, 5325 Village Market in Wesley Chapel
New River Branch Library, 34043 SR 54 in Zephyrhills
East Pasco Government Center, 14236 Sixth St. in Dade City
South Holiday Branch Library, 4649 Mile Stretch Drive in Holiday
West Pasco Government Center, 7530 Little Road in New Port Richey
Hudson Regional Library, 8012 Library Road in Hudson

Share this:

  • Tweet
  • Share on Tumblr
  • Email
  • Print

Like this:

Like Loading...

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Primary Sidebar

Search

Sponsored Content

New Community Garden Arrives at Del Webb Bexley 

March 28, 2023 By Kelli Carmack

Exciting things are happening at Del Webb Bexley, the 55+ active adult residential community just off Sunlake Boulevard, … [Read More...] about New Community Garden Arrives at Del Webb Bexley 

TPA-Parkview-Myrtle

Imagine More at Mattamy Homes’ Area Communities

March 28, 2023 By Kelli Carmack

With every new home community, Mattamy Homes demonstrates their dedication to thoughtful details and meaningful value … [Read More...] about Imagine More at Mattamy Homes’ Area Communities

More Posts from this Category

What’s Happening

04/01/2023 – Bunny Hop Eggstravaganza

The Land O’ Lakes Recreation Complex, 3032 Collier Parkway, will host a Bunny Hop Eggstravaganza on April 1 from 10:30 a.m. to 1 p.m. There will be bounce houses, games, music, food trucks, and scheduled egg scrambles. The event will be at the outside football fields and basketball court. Registration is required to participate in the egg scrambles. The cost is $3 per child. Children ages 2 to 10 can register with their age division and time frame at Secure.rec1.com/FL/pasco-county-fl/catalog. For questions, call 813-929-1220. … [Read More...] about 04/01/2023 – Bunny Hop Eggstravaganza

04/01/2023 – Cacti and Things

Kessler’s Cacti and Things will host its annual Spring Plant Sale on April 1 and April 2 from 9 a.m. to 4 p.m., rain or shine, at Bearss Grove, 14316 Lake Magdalene Blvd., in Tampa. The event features thousands of plant varieties, and an assortment of specimen and collector’s plants. For information, email . For questions and directions, call 813-264-5614. … [Read More...] about 04/01/2023 – Cacti and Things

04/01/2023 – Dade City Art Walk

The Downtown Dade City Art Walk will take place April 1 from 5 p.m. to 8 p.m. There will be more than 20 art locations for guests to meet the artists and shop local artwork, as well as a little Pre-Casso Exhibit for young aspiring artists. There will be an opening ceremony at 5 p.m., along with a map distribution, at Florida Cracker Lunch on Limoges. … [Read More...] about 04/01/2023 – Dade City Art Walk

04/01/2023 – Easter Bash

Hope City Church, 5513 School Road in Land O’ Lakes, will host an Easter Bash on April 1, for the whole family. Admission is free. For information, call 813-948-7555. … [Read More...] about 04/01/2023 – Easter Bash

04/01/2023 – Food Truck Festival

An International Food Truck Festival will take place on April 1 and April 2 at the Tampa Premium Outlets, 2300 Grand Cypress Drive in Lutz, with more than 70 food trucks, tents and trailers, to benefit local charities. Admission is $5. For more information, call 727-674-1464. … [Read More...] about 04/01/2023 – Food Truck Festival

04/01/2023 – Historical Association

The Zephyrhills Historical Association will meet on April 1 from 10 a.m. to 11:30 a.m., at the Zephyrhills Public Library, 5347 Eighth St. Participants can discover and discuss historical events, places and people of Zephyrhills and Pasco County. For information, call 813-780-0064. … [Read More...] about 04/01/2023 – Historical Association

More of What's Happening

Archives

 

 

Where to pick up The Laker and Lutz News

Copyright © 2023 Community News Publications Inc.

   
%d bloggers like this: